TIFF Day #5 – 2023

Hello Everyone,

My first film of the day was a story I knew in part because we’ve played material over the years at The Dayton LGBT Film Fest  (now known as OUT HERE DAYTON FILM FEST) about Bayard Rustin.  RUSTIN, dir George C. Wolfe (USA). “George C. Wolfe brings Bayard Rustin’s story to life, with a joyous performance by Colman Domingo as the activist who organized the 1963 March on Washington while being forced into the background because of his sexuality.” (TIFF Catalog)  I was a little nervous about this film with its opening scenes.  There was a little too much camera mugging and the tone seemed too easy and light…but I ultimately think it was a device to get the masses hooked into sitting down for a good history lesson. Rustin was ahead of his time for a lot of his reasons, and I hope people of all backgrounds check out this crowd pleasing film.  One line that really stood out for me was when Rustin talks about his detractors.  “The day I was born, I was born a homosexual.  They either believe in freedom and justice for all – or they don’t.”  Domingo is fantastic!

My second film of the day was a public screening, and Elliot Page and director Dominic Savage were in attendance. CLOSE TO YOU, dir. Dominic Savage (Canada, UK). “Sam (Elliot Page) has a chance encounter with an old friend (Hillary Baack) on his way home to a dreaded family reunion that forces him to confront long-buried memories.” (TIFF Catalog) This trans story about a man visiting family who hasn’t been home in almost 5 years has some really incredible moments.  In fact, there’s a moment when my audience burst into applause about 80 minutes into the film.  Savage’s process for filmmaking is to essentially have a draft…he knows where he wants the film to go and the trajectory of the story – but dialog is up to the actors.  Some takes go 20-50 minutes long as actors play their roles and figure out the material together.  Unfortunately, I felt like this rawness didn’t always work…there were some moments that seemed a little too stilted – as though some of the family members had never met (and maybe that’s the point…they never really did get to know each other) – but I can’t help but feel like more editing would help.  This film is worth it for a few key moments and for the original story.

At my next screening, I fell in love.  The three lead character’s in Alexander Payne’s new film are incredible.  THE HOLDOVERS, dir. Alexander Payne (USA). “Paul Giamatti stars in Alexander Payne’s latest about the bond that forms between a strict professor and a belligerent student he’s stuck supervising over the winter holiday at an elite boarding school.” (TIFF Catalog)  The screenplay to this film is gold, and the performances are spectacular.  Underneath the bristling and biting dialog are warm and tender moments that are well-earned. Alexander Payne was in attendance, and he spoke of his love for TIFF audiences.  He said he loves how cinema culture is woven into the fabric of Toronto life…and “for my money, Toronto is the Paris of North America.” Da’Vine Joy Randolph (who also had a very small part in RUSTIN) and Dominic Sessa will hopefully become even bigger stars! I loved this film…and I can’t wait to see it again.

My last film of the day has a big Dayton/Ohio connection.  Produced by Daytonian Karri O’Reilly, this film had a lot of familiar names attached.  I attended the premiere, and Karri was one of the very first people Ethan Hawke thanked.  He said that she “willed this film into being.” WILDCAT, dir. Ethan Hawke (USA). “Ethan Hawke explores the life and art of American author Flannery O’Connor — played by his own daughter, Maya Hawke — in his latest interrogation of the artist’s way.” (TIFF Catalog) This film is a bit complicated as it is about an writer’s process…we hop around from Flannery’s life to her inspirations and her stories – being told on-screen using people from her daily life – so I can already hear some of our customers saying they’re confused.  That said, if you let the film wash over you, the visual styles are different enough to let you understand where you are in Flannery’s early days of writing.  For such an “intimate” story, it’s a really big film…and Karri told me they were able to do it with a very modest budget.  Flannery O’Connor fans, literature fans and people who enjoy thoughtful, well-crafted films will find a lot to love in this film.  The Q&A after the film and the after-party were a blast.  I’ve attached a couple photos for you below.  Maya Hawke, Laura Linney and Christine Dye are all terrific in this film…and they (among numerous other cast and crew) were at the party.

The praises of Daytonian Karri O’Reilly were flowing from Ethan Hawke.  I even overheard “let’s do more” while posing for this pic!

Thanks for reading.  It’s super-late…and I have an 8:30 screening.

My best,

Jonathan