Dayton937

Things to do in Dayton | Restaurants, Theatre, Music and More

McCoy on Movies: Mean Girls

By

“Lindsey Lohan? Never heard of her …” Regina George (Reneé Rapp, center) holds court in the lunchroom with Gretchen Wieners (Bebe Wood) and Karen Shetty (Avantika) in a scene from Samantha Jayne and Arturo Perez, Jr.’s production of MEAN GIRLS. Credit: Jojo Whilden © 2023 Paramount Pictures. All rights reserved. 

WATCH THE TRAILER HERE:

 

 
KEY CAST MEMBERS: Angourie Rice, Jenna Fischer, Reneé Rapp, Auli’I Cravalho, Avantika, Bebe Wood, Jaquel Spivey, Christopher Briney with Busy Phillips, Tim Meadows and Tina Fey

DIRECTOR: Samantha Jayne and Arturo Perez Jr.
THE BACK STORY: Based on the hit musical – which itself is based on the original hit 2004 theatrical film – Mean Girls stars Angourie Rice as Cady Heron, a young girl who has been homeschooled by her mother (Jenna Fischer) while living in Kenya. Ms. Heron, however, has taken a job back in the United States, meaning Cady is about to get her first taste of what life is like in an American high school.

And that’s where she encounters a cast of characters that are going to change her life.

After meeting her new homeroom teacher Ms. Norbury (Tina Fey), Cady is observed by Janis (Auli’I Cravalho) and Damian (Jaquel Spivey), two social outcasts who quickly see she needs a rundown of the law of the land. That means letting her know about the Plastics, a.k.a. queen of the school Regina George (Reneé Rapp) and her two faithful underlings, the clueless Karen Shetty (Avantika) and the smart-yet-still-fearful-of-her Gretchen Wieners (Bebe Wood). None of this would be a problem for Cady if Regina hadn’t also taken an interest in her … And Cady took an interest in Aaron Samuels (Christopher Briney), a.k.a. her ex. 

So … What happens when you mix teenagers, insecurity, hormones and life lessons all to the beat of a diverse musical soundtrack? A film that is sure to turn plenty of potentially mean older fans into pleasantly surprised moviegoers …

THE REVIEW: The musical version of a beloved stage production … Sometimes, it can turn out great (like Les Misérables) …Other times, you get Cats. But creating a movie musical based on a stage musical that was originally a film that came out just 20 years – YUP, 2004 was two decades ago now – ago? Now that could be a daunting task for any directing duo … But for one that is primarily known for shorts and music videos like Samantha Jayne and Arturo Perez Jr.? It has “make or break” written all over it.

Fortunately for Jayne and Perez, Jr. – and fans of the original film – Mean Girls 2024 makes for an entertaining film fans old and new will enjoy.

 
Here’s what works well about the musical film adaptation of Mean Girls: The story is told efficiently through a clever mix of traditional dialogue and song, the latter diving deeper into their respective characters’ psyches, motivations, fears and insecurities in a way the original did not. In addition, the dance sequences enhance each moment or scene in similar fashion, serving as a complement rather than a distraction. 

None of this would matter, however, without the performances of the relatively unknown cast. Whereas Rice channels Cady with the same innocence Lindsey Lohan did in the original, Rapp owns pretty much every scene she’s in – while yet being more relatable arguably than Rachel McAdams was in the role in 2004. Wood likewise gives Gretchen considerable spunk and Avantika plays her role with such a wide-eyed aloofness it honors the work her predecessor Amanda Seyfried did and then some. 

Cravalho and newcomer Spivey, however, may have the best star turns of the entire affair, each bringing a dynamic (and needed) entertainment aspect to the film. Fey, Tim Meadows (reprising his role as the beleaguered Mr. Duvall) and the other adults are wise to mostly stay out of the way, letting the young people – even though it’s hard to buy in to most of the cast outside of Rice, Cravalho and Avantika being in their teens –  shine. Of course, Jayne and Perez, Jr. deserve kudos for their interpolation of TikTok and the modern world into the mix to deliver the best package possible – then again, having Fey on board for this go round likely helps.

Whether you prefer the 2024 version of Mean Girls likely comes down to how much you love the original versus you love musicals. The new one has all the exploration of the insanity that is high school, the humor and utlimately the empowerment that made the original so beloved by so many, plus a few new wrinkles thrown in for good measure. Thus, both are fine, both are entertaining …

And don’t worry, both are worthy of fetch-ing your attention.

 
OVERALL RATING (OUT OF FOUR POSSIBLE BUCKETS OF POPCORN):

[fbcomments width="700" count="on" num="15" countmsg="Comments"]