Saluting Dayton’s 2016-17 Theater Season

Productions centered on a sadistic barber wreaking havoc in Victorian London, stubborn Iowans forever changed by a charming con artist, America coping with race relations in turn of the century New York and 1960s Baltimore, a progressive novice sending shockwaves throughout a Catholic elementary school, an iconic record company reshaping the landscape of American music, and a legendary ship deemed unsinkable were among the best of Dayton’s 2016-17 theater season.

On professional stages, the Human Race Theatre Company’s 30th anniversary season was memorably illuminated by Scott Stoney’s immersive, ensemble-friendly Sweeney Todd (attended on opening night by Academy Award nominee Jesse Eisenberg of The Social Network) and the local premiere of Hail Mary!, a pleasantly surprising and gently thought-provoking character study. Hail Mary! was specifically bolstered by Claire Kennedy’s masterfully complex portrayal of a woman challenging authority for the betterment of her students.

 

Elsewhere, the Victoria Theatre Association offered outstanding national tours with Motown particularly rising to the top thanks to a splendidly versatile, crowd-pleasing cast. Dare to Defy Productions gave local talent exciting platforms to rediscover and reinterpret tried and true material (Mackensie King’s Children of Eden strikingly emphasized family ties and generational repercussions as never before). Female-centric Magnolia Theatre Company offered a riveting local premiere of tense parent-teacher conference drama Gidion’s Knot. Reliably edgy Playground Theatre delivered a local premiere of Jailbait overflowing with gripping realism as its searing account of love, deceit and embracing adulthood stirred to the core.

 

At community theaters, strong musicals as well as a fine balance of classic and contemporary fare enticed. Dayton Theatre Guild’s eclectic impulses served them well with local premieres of The Last Lifeboat, Luna Gale and Wonder of the World (heightened by sitcom savvy knockout Kari Carter) in addition to a mesmerizing Elephant Man accented by Jared Mola’s remarkable physicality. Dayton Playhouse scored with Ragtime, The Women, Xanadu, and another enjoyably competitive FutureFest (last year’s winner Shepherd’s Bush is now titled Nonsense and Beauty; powerfully acted Memories of the Game was named audience favorite). Senior-themed Young at Heart Players delighted with the overdue return of the adorable First Kisses, a 2003 FutureFest finalist. Brookville Community Theatre supplied a whimsically entertaining Beauty and the Beast. Beavercreek Community Theatre’s artistic risks paid off with a lovely, vocally impressive Nine (brought to life by Jeffrey Murphy in the vibrantly elegant spirit of original director Tommy Tune) and a commendable local premiere of Bonnie and Clyde.

Highlights from area colleges included Wright State University’s tap-happy No, No, Nanette and beautifully staged/designed Shakespearean play-with-music Restoration!, Cedarville University’s rousing and heartwarming Music Man, and Sinclair Community College’s darkly atmospheric Dracula. Other notables across the city included the Muse Machine’s tremendously feel-good Hairspray (featuring marvelously mature newcomer Fischer Barnett), Epiphany Lutheran Church’s better-than-Broadway Big Fish (expertly conceived by Megan Wean Sears), and under-the-radar-but-dynamic Standing on Ceremony (Sinclair), Hello Again (Wright State), and Four Women: A Tribute to Nina Simone & The Black Arts Movement (Oral Funk Poetry Productions and University of Dayton).

Assessing the 80 shows I saw last season, I congratulate the following winners (in bold) and nominees.

BEST TOURING PRODUCTION
42nd Street, Victoria Theatre Association
Elf, Victoria Theatre Association
Jersey Boys, Victoria Theatre Association
Kinky Boots, Victoria Theatre Association
Motown the Musical, Victoria Theatre Association

BEST PROFESSIONAL PRODUCTION OF A PLAY
Gidion’s Knot, Magnolia Theatre Company
Hail Mary!, Human Race Theatre Company
Jailbait, Playground Theatre
This is Our Youth, Playground Theatre
Thurgood, Human Race Theatre Company

BEST LOCALLY-PRODUCED PROFESSIONAL MUSICAL
The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee, Dare to Defy Productions
Children of Eden, Dare to Defy Productions
Dogfight: The Musical, Dare to Defy Productions
Guys and Dolls, Dare to Defy Productions
Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street, Human Race Theatre

BEST COMMUNITY THEATER PRODUCTION OF A PLAY
The Elephant Man, Dayton Theatre Guild
First Kisses, Young at Heart Players
The Last Lifeboat, Dayton Theatre Guild
Luna Gale, Dayton Theatre Guild
Vanya and Sonia and Masha and Spike, Beavercreek Community Theatre
The Women, Dayton Playhouse

BEST COMMUNITY THEATER PRODUCTION OF A MUSICAL
Disney’s Beauty and the Beast, Brookville Community Theatre
Bonnie and Clyde, Beavercreek Community Theatre
Nine, Beavercreek Community Theatre
Ragtime, Dayton Playhouse
Xanadu, Dayton Playhouse

BEST COLLEGIATE PRODUCTION OF A PLAY
A Midsummer Night’s Dream, Sinclair Community College
Angels in America: Perestroika, Clark State Community College
The Children’s Hour, Wright State University
Dracula, Sinclair Community College
Restoration!, Wright State University

BEST COLLEGIATE PRODUCTION OF A MUSICAL
9 to 5, Wright State University
Heathers, Wright State University
The Music Man, Cedarville University
No, No, Nanette, Wright State University
The Toxic Avenger, Sinclair Community College

BEST SPECIAL THEATRICAL EVENT
Big Fish, Epiphany Lutheran Church
Four Women: A Tribute to Nina Simone & The Black Arts Movement, Oral Funk Poetry Productions and University of Dayton
Hairspray, Muse Machine
Hello Again, Wright State University
Standing on Ceremony: The Gay Marriage Plays, Sinclair Community College

BEST NEW WORK
Daniel Goldstein’s Family Ties, Human Race Theatre Company
W.L. Newkirk’s [Miss], Dayton Playhouse FutureFest
Scott C. Sickles’ Shepherd’s Bush, Dayton Playhouse FutureFest
Kristy Sharron Thomas’ Memories of the Game, Dayton Playhouse FutureFest
Eric Ulloa’s 26 Pebbles, Human Race Theatre Company

BEST LEADING ACTOR IN A PLAY
Mike Beerbower as Robert, Jailbait
A.J. Breslin as Dennis, This Is Our Youth
Franklin Johnson as Kenneth McIntosh, Memories of the Game
Alan Bomar Jones as Thurgood Marshall, Thurgood
Jared Mola as John Merrick, The Elephant Man
Leo Santucci as Dracula, Dracula

BEST LEADING ACTRESS IN A PLAY
Jenna Gomes as Claire, Jailbait
Amy Handra as Heather Clark, Gidion’s Knot
Claire Kennedy as Mary Wytkowski, Hail Mary!
Cheryl Mellen as Caroline, Luna Gale
Andréa Morales as Corryn Fell, Gidion’s Knot
Marva Williams as Karen McIntosh, Memories of the Game

BEST LEADING ACTOR IN A MUSICAL
Jamie Cordes as Sweeney Todd, Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street
Robbie Lindmark as Harold Hill, The Music Man
Ron Mauer as Tateh, Ragtime
Kip Moore as Coalhouse Walker, Jr., Ragtime
Timothy Ware as Lola, Kinky Boots
Ray Zupp as Eddie Birdlace, Dogfight

BEST LEADING ACTRESS IN A MUSICAL
Esther Hyland as Eve, Children of Eden
Rachel Jensen as Mother, Ragtime
Mackensie King as Rose Fenny, Dogfight
Allison Semmes as Diana Ross, Motown the Musical
Maddie Vaughn as Veronica Sawyer, Heathers
Rebecca Watson as Mrs. Lovett, Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street

BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR IN A PLAY
Ross Bloedorn as Mr. Smith/Edgar, Restoration!
Geoff Burkman as Carr Gomm, The Elephant Man
Christopher Hahn as Mark, Jailbait
Charles Larkowski as Joe, Standing On Ceremony: The Gay Marriage Plays
Connor Lysholm as Mr. Jo Williams/Edmund/Bastard, Restoration!
Maximillian Santucci as Van Helsing, Dracula

BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS IN A PLAY
Catherine A. Collins as Clemma Diggins, Proposals (Dayton Playhouse)
Lisa Glover as Emmy, Jailbait
Debra Kent as Sonia, Vanya and Sonia and Masha and Spike
Heather Martin as Mrs. Kendal, The Elephant Man
Libby Scancarello as Mrs. Sylvia Fowler, The Women
Jennifer Dorr White as Mother Regina Marie, Hail Mary!

BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR IN A MUSICAL
Mark Antony Howard as Seaweed J. Stubbs, Hairspray
Brett Norgaard as Leaf Coneybear, The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee
Remy James Patterson as Marcellus Washburn, The Music Man
DJ Plunkett as Tobias Ragg, Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street
Layne Roate as Boland, Dogfight
Aaron Vega as The Beadle, Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street

BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS IN A MUSICAL
Natalie Girard as Heather Chandler, Heathers
Becky Howard as Emma Goldman, Ragtime
Krissy McKim-Barker as Mrs. Potts, Disney’s Beauty and the Beast
Tia Seay as Sarah, Ragtime
Sherri Sutter as Rona Lisa Peretti, The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee
Kimberly Warrick as Guido’s Mother, Nine

BREAKTHROUGH MALE PERFORMANCE
Fischer Barnett as Edna Turnblad, Hairspray
Naman Clark as Jerry, Standing on Ceremony: The Gay Marriage Plays
Brent Hoggatt as Chip Tolentino, The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee
S. Francis Livisay as Tom, Standing on Ceremony: The Gay Marriage Plays
Andrew Poplin as Peter, Luna Gale
Andre Reece Tomlinson as Michael McIntosh, Memories of the Game

BREAKTHROUGH FEMALE PERFORMANCE
Kari Carter as Cass Harris, Wonder of the World
Kennedy Cook as Motormouth Maybelle, Hairspray
Kayla Graham as Karlie, Luna Gale
Abby Land as Marcy Park, The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee
Nabachwa Ssensalo as Sharon Evans, Memories of the Game
Sarah Zaffiro as Sarraghina, Nine

BEST DIRECTION OF A PLAY
Kimberly Borst, Dracula
Michelle Hayford, Gidion’s Knot
W. Stuart McDowell, Restoration!
Margarett Perry, Hail Mary!
Jeff Sams, The Last Lifeboat
Jenna Valyn, Jailbait

BEST DIRECTION OF A MUSICAL
Rebecca Baker, The Music Man
Joe Deer and Lula Elzy, Hairspray
Mackensie King, Children of Eden
Jeffrey Murphy, Nine
Megan Wean Sears, Big Fish
Scott Stoney, Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street

BEST CHOREOGRAPHY
Carrie Anthony, The Music Man
Michael Baxter, No, No, Nanette
Lula Elzy, Hairspray
Michelle Lynch, Dirty Dancing – The Classic Story on Stage (Victoria Theatre Association)
Megan Wean Sears, 9 to 5
Nabachwa Ssensalo, Michael Shepherd and Michael Groomes, Ragtime

BEST SCENIC DESIGN OF A PLAY
Chris Harmon, Dracula
Chris Newman and David Shough, The Elephant Man
Chris Newman, Proposals (Dayton Playhouse)
Jeff Sams, The Last Lifeboat
Terry Stump, A Midsummer Night’s Dream

BEST SCENIC DESIGN OF A MUSICAL
J. Branson, Hairspray
Bob Clements, The Music Man
Dan Gray, Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street
Kacie Hultgren, 42nd Street
Pam Lavarnway, No, No, Nanette

BEST COSTUME DESIGN OF A PLAY
N. Lynn Brown, The Elephant Man
Carol Finley, The Last Lifeboat
Kathleen Hotmer, Dracula
Kathleen Hotmer, A Midsummer Night’s Dream
Christie Peitzmeijer, Restoration!

BEST COSTUME DESIGN OF A MUSICAL
Elizabeth Bourgeois, No, No, Nanette
Maria Klueber and Lori Watamaniuk, Big Fish
Janet G. Powell, Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street
Rebekah Priebe, The Music Man
Tiia E. Torchia, Toni Donato Shade and Alisa Vukasinovich, Hairspray

BEST LIGHTING DESIGN OF A PLAY
Matthew P. Benjamin, Restoration!
Daniel Brunk, Dracula
Travis Dwire, Gidion’s Knot
John Falkenbach, The Last Lifeboat
Jennifer Watson, The Children’s Hour

BEST LIGHTING DESIGN OF A MUSICAL
Jadon Bischoff, The Toxic Avenger
Bob Clements and Megan Howell, The Music Man
Jessica Ann Drayton, No, No, Nanette
Derryck Menard, Dogfight
John Rensel, Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street

BEST SOUND DESIGN OF A PLAY
Jay Brunner, Family Ties
Jay Brunner, On Golden Pond
Ryan Burgdorf, Restoration!
Isaiah Parnell, Dracula
K.L. Storer, The Last Lifeboat

BEST SOUND DESIGN OF A MUSICAL
Daniel Brunk, The Toxic Avenger
Jay Brunner, Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street
James Dunlap, Heathers
Bob Kovach, Xanadu
Sam Partridge, The Music Man

BEST ORCHESTRA
Children of Eden, Musical Director: Lorri Topping
Hairspray, Musical Director: Sean Michael Flowers
The Music Man, Musical Director: Jeff Beste; Orchestra Conductor: Carlos Elias
No, No, Nanette, Musical Director: Scot Woolley
Ragtime, Musical Director: Ron Kindell

BEST PROPERTIES
Sarah Gomes, Dracula
John Lavarnway, Restoration!
Marly Masterson, The Last Lifeboat
Victoria Osewski, The Elephant Man
Heather Powell, Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street

ADDITIONAL ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

• The cast of Family Ties: Thea Brooks as Mallory, Sara Mackie as Jennifer, Eve Plumb as Elyse, Maggie Lou Rader as Ellen, Lawrence Redmond as Steven, and Jim Stanek as Alex
• The cast of Hello Again: Celia Arthur as The Whore, Philip Stock as The Soldier, Rachel Green as The Nurse, Kyle Miller as The College Boy, Megan Valle as The Young Wife, Kyle Krichbaum as The Husband, Zach Fretag as The Young Thing, Eli Davis as The Writer, Robin Dunavent as The Actress, and Christian Schaefer as The Senator
• The cast of The Last Lifeboat: Matt Lindsay as J. Bruce Ismay, Heather Atkinson as Mrs. Ryerson and Others, Mike Beerbower as William Randolph Hearst and Others, Cassandra Engber as Vivian Hilliard and Others, Zach Katris as Phillip Franklin and Others, Heather Martin as Florence Ismay and Others, Kerry Simpson as Margaret Ismay and Others, and J. Gary Thompson as Thomas Ismay and Others
• The cast of Nine: Brice Thomas as Guido Contini, Micah Koverman as Young Guido, Shannon Carlson as Luisa, Hayley Penchoff as Carla, Danielle DeLorme as Claudia, Kimberly Warrick as Guido’s Mother, Joyce Murphy as Liliane La Fleur, Cynthia Karns as Lina Darling, Courtney Kakac as Stephanie Necrophorus, Meghan McConnell as Our Lady of the Spa, Sarah Zaffiro as Sarraghina, Renee Franck-Reed as Renata, Aeriel Aniballi as Annabella, Krista Ann Werts as Francesca, and Jack Lockwood and Max Kieselhorst as Young Guido’s school mates
• The cast of On Golden Pond (Human Race Theatre Company): Kaleb Barlow as Billy Ray, Charlie Clark as Charlie Martin, Ken Early as Bill Ray, Dale Hodges as Ethel Thayer, Jennifer Joplin as Chelsea Thayer Wayne, and Joneal Joplin as Norman Thayer
• The cast of Vanya and Sonia and Masha and Spike: Cassandra Engber as Masha, Debra Kent as Sonia, Charles Larkowski as Vanya, Cassidy Manley as Nina, Erin McGee as Cassandra, and Ryan Petrie as Spike; Also, Charles Larkowski’s interpretation of Vanya’s tirade
• The cast of The Women: Rachel Oprea as Mary, Tori Toccillo as Nancy, Yara Khalil as Peggy, Libby Scancarello as Sylvia, Amy Taint as Edith, Jenna Gomes as Crystal Allen, Renee Franck-Reed as Countess De Lage, Marcia Nowik as Mrs. Morehead, Ashley Sisson as Jane, Danikah Skaroupka as Little Mary, and ensemble members Tamar Fishbein, Carrin Ragland, Heather Carrell, Caitlin Blackford, Becky Howard, Cheryl Mellen, Lindsey Cardoza, and Tiffany Williams
• The ensemble of Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street: Gina Handy, Drew Helton, Scott Hunt, Cassi Mikat, Nathan Robert Pecchia, David Shough, Sherri L. Sutter, and Kandis Wean
• Children of Eden’s Storytellers: Lisa Glover, Kaitlyn Hiltibran, Zach King, Danielle Kubasky, Bobby Mitchum, Brennan Paulin, T.C. Schreier, Tia Seay, Angie Thacker, Desmond Thomas, Jesse Daniel Trieger, and William Boatwright
• Lola’s Angels in Kinky Boots: Joseph Anthony Byrd, Tony d’Alelio, John J. Dempsey, Ian Gallagher Fitzgerald, Xavier Reyes, and Andy Richardson
• Amy Askins as Melpomene, Tamar Fishbein as Calliope, and John Nussbaum as Young Danny and Centaur in Xanadu
• Sandy Bashaw and W. Stuart McDowell’s music for Restoration!
• Kyle Bates as Link Larkin, Jack Blair as Corny Collins, Amber Butler as Little Inez, Adam Clark as Mr. Pinky, Lauren Eifert as Amber Von Tussle, Kaite Hubler as Tracy Turnblad, Clare Kneblik as Velma Von Tussle, Jack Lewis as Wilbur Turnblad, Ana Smith as Penny Pingleton, and Michelle Strauss as Gym Teacher/Matron in Hairspray
• Kyle Bates as Billy Crocker and Cecily Dowd as Reno Sweeney in Anything Goes (Centerville High School)
• N. Lynn Brown’s costumes for Nine
• Jay Brunner’s original music for On Golden Pond
• Saul Caplan as Roy Cohn and Jared Mola as Prior Walter in Angels in America: Perestroika
• Circus 1903, Victoria Theatre Association
• Sarah Clark as Belle, Preston Eberlyn as The Beast, and Andrew Sollenberger as Lumiere in Disney’s Beauty and the Beast
• William G.L. Courson’s flying direction, Kaoime E. Malloy’s blood and special effects, Gina Neuerer’s projection design, Gary Minyard’s fight choreography, and Brooke Watson’s wig and makeup design for Dracula
• Bailey Edmonds as Violet Newstead, Natalie Girard as Doralee Rhodes and Meredith Zahn as Judy Bernly in 9 to 5
• Sean Michael Flowers’ musical direction of Hello Again
• Nick Garvin’s piano accompaniment for Dogfight
• Ray Geiger as Tom Durnin and Karen Righter as Karen Brown-Canedy in The Unavoidable Disappearance of Tom Durnin (Dayton Theatre Guild)
• Lisa Glover’s choreography for Children of Eden, Dogfight and Guys and Dolls
• Chester Gregory as Berry Gordy, Jarran Muse as Marvin Gaye, David Kaverman as Smokey Robinson, Emilio Sosa’s costumes, and Patricia Wilcox and Warren Adams’ choreography in Motown the Musical
• Patrick Allyn Hayes’ Toxie mask and suit design for The Toxic Avenger
• Tamara L. Honesty’s set design for Family Ties
• In the roles of Sky Masterson and Sarah Brown, Bryan Hupp and Esther Hyland’s rendition of “I’ve Never Been in Love Before” in Guys and Dolls
• Barbara Jorgensen as Peg Concannon and Fred Blumenthal’s scenic design in The Outgoing Tide (Dayton Theatre Guild)
• Theresa Kahle’s costumes and Steve Burton’s wig designs for Ragtime
• Debra Kent as Alexandra Benton and Robb Willoughby as Chris Benton in The Velocity of Autumn (Undercroft Players)
• Matt Lindsay as Quince/Prologue, Tristan Rivera as Snug/Lion, Jonathan Kelly as Bottom/Pyramus, Elisha Chamberlin as Flute/Thisby, and Spencer Boden as Snout/Wall in A Midsummer Night’s Dream
• TJ Montgomery as Clyde Barrow, Kami Flanders as Bonnie Parker, Sam Hamilton as Buck Barrow, Jackie Darnell as Blanche Barrow, Aaron Brewer as Ted Hinton, and Josh Clifford as Preacher in Bonnie and Clyde
• Dakota Mullins as Billy Early and his execution of “Call of the Sea” in No, No, Nanette
• Annie Pesch as Mary and J. Gary Thompson as John in First Kisses
• Rachel Joy Rowland as Marian Paroo and Jonathan Kimble as Winthrop Paroo in The Music Man
• Megan Wean Sears’ choreography for Big Fish
• Tia Seay as Crystal, Samantha Wright-Norman as Ronnette, and Courtney Dortch as Chiffon in Little Shop of Horrors (Dare to Defy Productions)
• David Shough as E.M. Forster and Brian Sharp as J.R. Ackerley in Shepherd’s Bush
• Randy Skinner’s Tony Award-nominated choreography (recreated by Stephanie Brooks) and Roger Kirk’s Tony Award-nominated costumes for 42nd Street
• John Slate and David Hapner’s piano accompaniment for No, No, Nanette
• Debra Strauss as Barbara, Helicopter Pilot, Waitresses, and Janie in Wonder of the World
• Christopher Tierney as Johnny Castle, Jillian Mueller as Frances “Baby” Houseman, Jennifer Mealani Jones as Penny Johnson, and Jon Driscoll’s video and projection design in Dirty Dancing – The Classic Story on Stage (Victoria Theatre Association)
• Andrea Wilborn as Sarah’s Friend leading “Till We Reach That Day” in Ragtime
• Zoot Theatre Company’s collaborative Angels in America with Columbus’ Short North Stage featuring puppet design by Tristan Cupp