It may be the most popular dessert at Thanksgiving dinners, but pumpkin pie didn’t make an appearance at the First Thanksgiving. The Pilgrims probably lacked the butter and flour needed to make a pie crust, and it’s not clear that they even had an oven in which they could have baked a pumpkin pie.
Speaking of baking- if you’re responsible for bringing the pie to your holiday dinner, here’s a quick round-up of places to pick up those sweet treats if you don’t have the time or talent to make them yourself:
Ashley’s Pastry Shop
21 Park Ave, Oakwood
Apple, Cherry, Pumpkin, Pecan, Lemon Meringue or Mince Meat
While you’re there pick up specialty breads, rolls, decorated cookies, pumpkin rolls and more!
Orange pumpkin on blue rustic wooden table.
1201 Wayne Ave, South Park
(937) 985-2633
You are encouraged to use the above link to order online.
Deadline to order is Sat, Nov 18th at noon. Pick up is Tues or Wed afternoon
Choose from Ghostlight Thanksgiving Pie. Mama Smiths Fantastic Apple Pie, Pumpkin & Maple, Kentucky Bourbon Pecan Pie. You can also order gluten-free dinner rolls and sweets like snickerdoodles and more.
All pies are completely homemade just like grandma made. We will be making:
Pumpkin pie, Apple Pie, Cherry Pie, Blackberry Pie, Key lime Pie,
Coconut Cream Pie, Chocolate Cream pie, Pecan Pie, Lemon Meringue Pie,
Butterscotch Pie and Peanut Butter Pie. All pies start at $13 each
3013 Linden Ave, Dayton
(937) 253-1163
Offering about 30 kinds of pie and a seasonal pumpkin roll order a couple of days ahead for special requests or stop by to pick up traditional Thanksgiving flavors like apple, pecan and pumpkin for under $10.
1050 Miamisburg Centerville Road
Dayton, Ohio, 45458
You can order online at the link above from a selection that includes apple pie, bittersweet chocolate Pecan Pie, pumpkin s’more crunch pie, gluten free pies that include apple, pumpkin, pecan (pictured) and cherry. Pies range from $10-$16
Tina’s Sweet Treats (A Gluten Free Bakery)
(513) 429-9428
Bakery Thanksgiving Pie Menu
Deadline-Saturday, Nov 18th
Pick up is Wednesday, November 22nd 10:00-7:00
All pies are 9”
Pumpkin-$16.00, Pecan-$16.00*, Cherry Crumble-$16.00*
Apple Crumble-$16.00*, Cranberry Apple-$18.00*
Caramel Apple-$20.00, Bourbon Sweet Potato w/Pecan Topping-$20.00
Frozen Unbaked Pie Shell-$5.00*
Dinner Rolls (1/2 dozen)-$4.50*
*-Dairy Free option available
To place order: comment on this post, send us a private facebook message, or email us at [email protected]
You can also find their Unbaked Pie Shells at Jungle Jim’s International Market Fairfield, Jungle Jim’s International Market Eastgate, and all 3 Dorothy Lane Market locations in the freezer section
Here’s another tip:
And if you’re really running tight on time- DoorDash can pick up your pies around town. Use the blue link for them and get $7 off your first delivery.
