It’s just not Thanksgiving without pie. Culinary historians date the tradition of serving pie on Thanksgiving back to the 18th century, and judging by modern search trends, pie is still the Thanksgiving dessert of choice today. The art of baking pies has been handed down for generations, but if handing out in the kitchen, measuring and baking isn’t your thing- no worries, there are plenty of options for you to just order your pies. Check these out!
Ghostlight Coffee
800 S. Patterson Blvd, Dayton
Preorder online. Orders being accepted until Noon, Sat. Nov. 21
The Lumberjack Pie
10″ ~ Serves 10-12 ~ $20
This might be the most addictive pie on your buffet (so make the slices small!). A combination of salty & sweet: a crispy, cinnamon-y cookie inspired crust is filled with ooey-gooey, buttery, custard-y, maple-y goodness. It’s delightful (good luck keeping Uncle Joe out of this one!)
Allergen Info: Dairy, Egg, Gluten (Wheat), Soy
The Pumpkin & Maple Pie
Baked from scratch by the Ghostlight Bakehouse
Vegan. 10″ ~ Serves 8-10 ~ $18
Traditional, but reimagined for everyone! Pumpkin Pie with Maple Syrup, Autumn Spices & Creamy Vanilla. Allergen Info: Gluten (Wheat), Soy
The Kentucky Bourbon Pecan Pie
Baked from scratch by the Ghostlight Bakehouse
10″ ~ Serves 8-10 ~ $19
Sure to become a family favorite! Pecan Pie gussied up with a splash (or few) of Kentucky Bourbon. Allergen Info: Milk (Dairy), Egg, Tree Nuts (Almond, Pecan), Gluten (Wheat), Soy Note: this pie contains Alcohol as an ingredient.
Cranberry Apple Crumble Pie
Baked from scratch by Tina’s Sweet Treats Dairy Free. Gluten Free. 9″ ~ Serves 8-10 ~ $19
Our friends at Tina’s Sweet Treats are offering this delicious Gluten AND Dairy Free option for our customers! It’s Tina’s popular Apple Pie with Tart Cranberries. Allergen Info: Dairy, Tree Nuts, Egg
The Bourbon Sweet Potato Pie
Baked from scratch by Tina’s Sweet Treats Gluten Free. 9″ ~ Serves 8 ~ $22
Another amazing GLUTEN FREE option from Tina that will surely please your family. This Sweet Potato Pie is kicked up a notch with a few glogs of Kentucky Bourbon, but wait! There’s more! It’s topped with Candied Pecans! Allergen Info: Dairy, Tree Nuts, Egg
All orders to be picked up at Ghostlight Coffee Midtown TUES 11/24 -or- WED 11/25 12 Noon – 6pm
Other special pick-up requests, please email [email protected] to discuss (charges apply)
Salt Block Biscuit Company
115 East Third Street, Dayton 937-938-9079
Cobblers, Pies, Biscuits, Cookies & much more
Or message on Instagram or Facebook
Cut off date for ordering November 23rd
Pick up by November 25th
Closed on Thanksgiving
Ashley’s Pastry Shop
21 Park Ave, Oakwood (937) 293-1719
We’ve got a variety of pies, bread, and cookies that are sure to make your Thanksgiving day a little sweeter! Call today to place your order. Don’t forget about our butterscotch rolls. Order early.
Partial to Pie
200 Shroyer Rd., Dayton. 937-813-8851
Already Sold Out for Thanksgiving week orders
700 Troy St., Old North Dayton 937-228-4151
Sweet potato, pecan, and peanut butter pies, pumpkin roll, cookies as well as rolls and other goodies
Say Yes Cakes
2920 Wayne Avenue, Dayton 937-938-9352
PIES- Bob Andy, pumpkin, pecan, apple, and sweet potato
PUMPKIN ROLLS
Traditional -half roll for $7 -whole roll for $14
Chocolate covered chocolate chip pumpkin roll
-half roll for $9. -whole roll for $18
White chocolate covered pumpkin roll
-half roll for $8 -whole roll for $16
Mehaffies Pies
3013 Linden Ave, Dayton (888) 289-7437 (937) 424-3425
With over 40 types of pies, the most popular for Thanksgiving are apple, pecan and pumpkin. Pies start at $9
72 hour notice requested.
Got a favorite pie shop we’ve missed? Drop us a note with details and we’ll add them.
Each year the baking elves at 
The Lumberjack pie is a combination of salty & sweet: a crispy, cinnamon-y cookie inspired crust is filled with ooey-gooey, buttery, custard-y, maple-y goodness. I had a piece of this pie last night and could not wait to get up and have another piece for breakfast. Order two of these – one to leave at home (you can even stick it in your freezer to enjoy later) and one to take to your Thanksgiving dinner – you’ll thank me later for this. This pie runs $18 and will easily serve 12 people- it’s incredible rich, so you can make your slices very small and you’ll still be very satisfied.
