• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to secondary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • Event Calendar
    • Submit An Event
  • About Us
    • Our Contributors
    • Subscribe
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Where to Pick up Dayton937
  • Arts & Entertainment
    • Art Exhibits
    • Comedy
    • On Screen Dayton
    • On Screen Dayton Reviews
    • Road Trippin’
      • Cincinnati
      • Columbus
      • Indianapolis
    • Spectator Sports
    • Street-Level Art
    • Visual Arts
  • Dayton Dining
    • Happy Hours Around Town
    • Local Restaurants Open On Monday
    • Patio Dining in the Miami Valley
    • 937’s Boozy Brunch Guide
    • Dog Friendly Patio’s in the Miami Valley
    • Restaurants with Private Dining Rooms
    • Dayton Food Trucks
    • Quest
    • Ten Questions
  • Dayton Music
    • Music Calendar
  • Active Living
    • Canoeing/Kayaking
    • Cycling
    • Hiking/Backpacking
    • Runners

Dayton937

Things to do in Dayton | Restaurants, Theatre, Music and More

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest

Coldwater Cafe

Coldwater Cafe Reveals Fall Menu

October 14, 2023 By Dayton937

Coldwater Cafe is a restaurant in a former bank building in the heart of Tipp City. The sophisticated restaurant is a lovely surprise for the small town of Tipp City with its inviting ambience, cozy fireplace, lovely upper deck and amazing food. The menu is eclectic and changes every season. Chef Katy Evans presents her fall 2023 menu:

Be sure and save room for Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Pie STUFFED Maple Cheesecake with a Biscoff Graham crust. That’s right, they’ve baked an ENTIRE pie into a cheesecake.


Coldwater Cafe
19 E Main St
Tipp City, OH 45371

(937) 667-0007

Tues- Thurs 11am – 8pm

Fri & Sat 11am – 9pm

Filed Under: Dayton Dining, The Featured Articles Tagged With: Chef Katy Evans, Coldwater Cafe, tipp City

Coldwater Cafe remains one of the area’s BEST!

July 29, 2022 By Joshua Stucky

“I haven’t been there in a while….how was it?” since COVID, that question has been asked about everything from KINGS ISLAND to AX THROWING, THE SCHUSTER CENTER to RIVERSCAPE. One restaurant where the answer is a consistent ‘It was amazing’ is the Coldwater Cafe in Tipp City. 5 hungry men headed up 75 North on a hot day in July to see how the Cafe was doing! Hard to put into words the experience we had.

To start, imagine a 95 degree evening, sun beating on the sidewalks…you pull into to Tipp City, and like a miracle of God, the front space at Coldwater is wide open. That earns 1 star…more to come.

We were seated on time for our reservation, which has become a crapshoot for many restaurant goers. Star! From there, we were greeted by our waitress, Kelly, a longtime server for the Cafe, who got down to business immediately….martinis, wine, beer….she knew her crowd! Another Star! We ordered some appetizers, the charcuterie, which was literally a spot-on array of meat, cheese, sweets and savories. To complement, we added the mussels (one of the diners with us is a mussel snob and he gave them two thumbs way up!.) There wasn’t a morsel left from our first course. STAR!

***Out came the warm hand towels…I mean, who doesn’t love the warm hand towel!! (A Coldwater Staple!)  STAR!

As we chatted and enjoyed some wine and bread, Kelly kept us well entertained, joining our fun and adding her own take on things. When dinner arrived, seamlessly timed, 5 men were very happy. Lobster-Crab cakes were a hit! The NY Strip got rave reviews! The AHI tuna salad scored high and everyone talked, at length, about how their dinner was ‘the best!’ STAR!

Before we could ask for checks, Kelly recommended their homemade desserts….I mean, we were FULL! And then….’you must have the carrot cake’ (we did, delicious); ‘you must have the bread pudding’ (we did, home-run); and you must have the chocolate cake (we did….wowzer!). STARS!!

We sat, center of the dining room just talking about the experience! It was one of those nights when everything clicked…and that seems to be the energy of Coldwater Cafe! Solid. Scrumptious and Social. The ingredients are all there…you should be too!

STARS all around!

Here’s the new summer menu:

 


Coldwater Cafe

19 E. Main Street,
Tipp City, OH. 45371

(937) 667-0007

Tues – Thurs 11am – 8pm

Fri & Sat 11am – 9pm

Filed Under: Community, Dayton Dining, The Featured Articles Tagged With: Coldwater Cafe

Coldwater Cafe Launches New Menu

July 29, 2020 By Lisa Grigsby

Chef Katy Fischer of Coldwater Cafe in Tipp City has introduced a new menu starting today in their European styled dining room. The restaurant is open 11 am until 8 pm Tuesday through Thursday and 11 am until 9 pm Friday and Saturday.   They  are taking reservations for BOTH lunch and dinner at this time! You can make a reservation online using OpenTable.

Check it out below:

 

Filed Under: Dayton Dining, The Featured Articles Tagged With: Chef Katy, Coldwater Cafe

10?’s with Chef Katy Fischer

May 6, 2020 By Lisa Grigsby

Katy Fischer is originally from Urbana, Ohio and always knew she wanted to become a chef from an early age. She studied at the Pennsylvania Culinary Institute in Pittsburgh. After graduating, she traveled the US working in many five star resorts polishing her talents in the kitchen. One of her favorite places was Savannah, Georgia where she worked under a French Chef who taught her the art of Southern cuisine.

In 2011 Katy moved back to town to spend time with her family and met the love of her life, Jeremy. She has been with Coldwater Cafe in Tipp City for 8 years and she has been the Executive Chef since 2015. Her culinary talents have brought many new customers by enlightening their taste buds with her unique creations. When Katy isn’t creating masterpieces, she loves spending time with Jeremy in Key West and with their three dogs, Lu, Merle, and Huckleberry, whom she considers her children.

Katy took some time to answer our Chef 10? interview and here’s what she had to say:

What is your favorite ingredient to cook with? 
My favorite ingredient to cook with isn’t a specific ingredient…but I would say spice. I love spicy food. The spicier the better. At Coldwater, I definitely hold back the heat as many people aren’t as crazy about it as I am. But let me be clear, I do not like things to just be hot, they have to be flavorful as well. There are so many ingredients out there that infuse dishes that I wish people would be more open to. There are so many amazing chiles that are underutilized. I love harissa, curry, masalas…there are just so many.

 

What ingredient do you dread?
Hmmm. I would have to say veal. I personally do not cook or eat veal. For my own personal reasons. I am an animal lover and not a lover of animal cruelty.

 

What’s your favorite dish to make?
Soup! Random answer, I know. But at Coldwater, we are known for our soups. We have a Soup of the Day and I am always creating new things. You can make soup out of anything. I just made a green tomato bisque full of fresh basil and lime juice and topped it with a crab and jalapeno salad. Killer.

 

What’s your favorite pig out food?
Oh gosh, well I’d say sushi….I love sushi! I could probably eat an entire sushi boat by myself. Ha…and that pickled ginger, yum!

 

What restaurant, other than your own, do you like to dine at in the Miami Valley?
I love Thai Nine. Like I said before, I’m a spicy kind of lady…I always ask what the hottest number is when I order and then ask them to make it even spicier. They have amazing Curry and Pad Thai. I also love the “surprise” sushi roll, that’s always fun. I love that when I go there, they treat me so well. They know I am the Chef at Coldwater and I love that the employees are fan of us as well. I love the support.

 

What’s your best advice for home chefs?
My best advice to Home Chefs would be to not take things too seriously. Recipes are guidelines. Have fun with what you’re doing and try new things, because I promise you the best things in life were created by accident.

 

If you could invite any 4 guests to a dinner party who would they be and why?
Four guests (can I choose alive or dead?) 1. Emeril Lagasse – he was one of the reasons I decided to become a Chef. His cooking shows were about all I watched as a teenager. I was always asking my Mom to get me the ingredients for his recipes I saw him making and she did! 2. Elton John – he’s done it all. His music is amazing, he’s not afraid to stand out in a crowd, he’s an activist, he’s an inspiration, and he just seems like he’d have a lot of great stories to tell. 3. Ellen DeGeneres – she’s hilarious, witty, kind, genuine, generous, an animal lover and activist, and I know we would have so much to talk about. 4. My Mom – she’s my number one fan. She’s always been there supporting me every step of the way. She’s the main reason I became a Chef. She was always cooking and baking and I loved being around her and doing anything she was doing. I still do.

 

Who do you look up to in the industry and why?
Honestly, I look up to all the Chefs I see killin’ it on Instagram. The chefs who are always being tagged on True Cooks. The chefs that are out there day in and day out, busting their butts, making delicious and beautiful food. The chefs who are driven by the passion we as chefs all have inside of us. Being a chef is not for the faint of heart. When you’re passionate and dedicated enough to be a chef, you may not see the light of day. You spend it in a kitchen, creating art to make other’s happy. You go home, sleep, and get up and do it again. All for the passion.

 

What do you do in the Miami Valley on a day off?
On my days off I enjoy kayaking in the Great Miami near Troy and Tipp City, hiking in Yellow Springs, trying new wineries, riding my bicycle, walking my three pups, gardening ( I plant and take care of lots of succulents)

 

Share a kitchen disaster, lucky break or other interesting story:
Oh the kitchen stories I could tell you- well just the other day we had sold roughly 70 Charcuterie kits and I was prepping more cheese when my hand slipped off the tip of my knife. My knife went through my hand cutting through three layers of skin. 6 stitches later, I came back to work, and everyone got their Charcuterie boards.

 

Filed Under: Dayton Dining, Ten Questions, The Featured Articles Tagged With: Chef Katy, Coldwater Cafe, Katy Fischer

Tipp City Restaurant Offers Date Night Meal Kit & Virtual Cooking Class

April 27, 2020 By Lisa Grigsby

Tipp City’s Coldwater Cafe has created the perfect date night meal box for two to add some fun to your quarantine meal time.  Executive Chef Katy Fischer will lead buyers through a virtual cooking class to prepare the 3 course meal this Saturday night at 7pm.
The $89.99 Date Night Meal Box will include the makings for this meal for two:

Traditional Caesar Salad

Halibut with Parmesan and Asparagus Risotto with chimichuri sauce

Mini Key Lime Pie

Your choice of a bottle  white wine -an Unoaked Chardonay from France 2018 or an Organic Red Wine from Spain

Instructions for cooking will be included with the box, and you can tune into to Coldwater’s Facebook Live where Chef Katy and her sous Chef Brian will provide a virtual cooking class to lead you through the process of cooking your date box meal.

Call Coldwater 937- 667-0007 or use facebook messenger to reserve your bottle (include your name, phone # and red or white for your bottle of wine.

Chef Katy

Box Pick up will be on  Friday May 1st from noon -7pm

Chef Katy also shared that next week they’ll have a Kids Cooking Box, that will include ingredients for a meal for 2 adults and 2 children- more details will be available soon, watch their facebook page for more info.


Coldwater Cafe

19 E Main St
Tipp City, Ohio

 INFORMATION DURING COVID-19 CARRYOUT ONLY

Adjusted hours are 11 am until 7 pm Tuesday through Saturday.

Click for our Adjusted Lunch Menu available from 11 am until 4 pm and for Adjusted Dinner Menu available from 4 pm until 7 pm.

Feel like a bottle of WINE to enjoy with your dinner?  They are selling our bottles at retail pricing!

Filed Under: Dayton Dining, The Featured Articles Tagged With: Chef Katy, Coldwater Cafe

Primary Sidebar

Submit An Event to Dayton937

Join the Dayton937 Newsletter!

Trust us with your email address and we'll send you our most important updates!
Email:  
For Email Marketing you can trust
Back to Top

Copyright © 2025 Dayton Most Metro · Terms & Conditions · Log in